Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada

Amara Cay Resort - A waterfront Keys retreat with private beach access, marina services, and ocean-view dining

Located along Islamorada's shoreline facing Alligator Reef Lighthouse, this 4-star Islamorada hotel combines 376-square-foot rooms and spacious suites featuring private balconies or lanais with coastal-inspired décor. The property includes ReelCatch restaurant serving fresh seafood, Coastal Cup café, and a poolside Tiki Bar offering classic American cuisine. A zero-entry pool with in-water loungers, fitness center, and private beach area with thatched huts provide recreation options. For water enthusiasts, the resort maintains a dock with wet slips and partners with two boat excursion companies. Guest rooms feature premium bedding, upscale toiletries, Keurig coffee makers, and HDTVs. Situated between mile markers 77 and 85, the property offers complimentary shuttle service within a four-mile radius.

Pros

Private furnished balconies and lanais with lighthouse or ocean views

Complimentary water taxi service to three sister resorts

On-site dock with boat excursion partners and marina services

Zero-entry pool with in-water loungers and poolside dining

Cons

3 miles from History of Diving Museum

Limited dining options within walking distance