American Beech Hotel, Greenport

American Beech Hotel - A boutique 4-star property in historic Stirling Square with restaurant, cocktail bars, and garden

Situated in a 19th-century building in historic Stirling Square, this Greenport hotel features 11 individually designed rooms and suites ranging from 320 to 620 square feet. American Beech accommodations include premium bedding, air conditioning, minibars, and flat-screen TVs with streaming services. The property houses three distinct dining venues: a modern American restaurant serving locally sourced cuisine, the outdoor Tree Bar with covered patio seating, and the Black Llama Cocktail & Oyster Bar. A private dining room accommodates up to 16 guests, while the main restaurant seats 55 indoors and 45 on the patio. The hotel provides free bikes for guest use and maintains a dog-friendly policy for pets under 50 pounds in designated rooms. Located within a 5-minute walk of the Long Island Railroad station and Hampton Jitney stop, the property sits 0.5 miles from downtown boutiques and 0.5 miles from the East End Seaport Maritime Museum.

Pros

Three distinct bars including a seasonal outdoor Tree Bar and intimate Black Llama Cocktail & Oyster Bar

Walking distance to train station, ferry terminals, and waterfront attractions

Pet-friendly rooms available with specific amenities for dogs

Paperless operation with modern booking and check-in systems

Cons

52.5 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport

Street parking only, with no dedicated hotel lot