Sunset Inn offers 20-25 rooms in four buildings, each with air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, a flat-screen TV, and free toiletries (Beekman 1802 brand). Rooms are spacious with comfortable beds, white linens, and modern furnishings. Some rooms include kitchenettes with coffee makers and microwaves. The bathrooms are small but have modern showers. Rooms face either the busy Overseas Highway (with hurricane-rated windows to reduce noise) or a quiet residential street. A back door in some rooms leads directly to the pool area.
Dining Options
The hotel has no on-site restaurant, but Mangrove Mike's Cafe is right next door and serves large breakfast portions. Lorelei Restaurant & Bar, a 5-minute walk via the back street, offers harbor-side dining, sunset views, and live music. Islamorada Brewery is across the street. Several other restaurants, tiki bars, and shops are within 2 km north or south on the highway.
Leisure and Entertainment
The heated outdoor swimming pool (open year-round) is surrounded by sun chairs and patio furniture. Guests can use the BBQ grills, picnic areas, and garden. Outdoor games include a giant chess board and ping-pong table. Free bikes are available to explore the area. The pool area is quiet and set back from the road.
Location and Transportation
Sunset Inn is on US Highway 1 in the center of Islamorada (Upper Matecumbe Key). It is less than 1 km from Upper Matecumbe Key, 4 km from Theater of the Sea, and 5 km from Windley Key. Walking distance to the History of Diving Museum and Anne's Beach. Robbie's Marina (for tarpon feeding and water activities) is a 5-minute drive. Miami International Airport is 100 km away. Free parking is available, and the hotel is accessible via the Overseas Highway.
Services and Policies
Services include free parking (including accessible spaces), daily housekeeping by request, and a front desk that provides local recommendations (e.g., prints confirmation for free park entry). Guests can borrow bikes and beach towels. The hotel is pet-friendly. Safety features: smoke alarms, fire extinguishers, key access. Note: rooms do not have microwaves; a shared microwave is near the ice machine. A daily resort fee of about $15 per guest applies.
“This establishment has managed to update a classic Florida motel feel with considerable success. The staff consistently proved helpful and professional, and the comfort of the rooms, particularly the beds, stands out. Its central location makes accessing local dining and attractions remarkably easy, all while providing a genuinely pleasant pool area for relaxation.”
Isabella MooreSenior Editorial Director at Petfriendlyhotels
Select your room type
Cozy rooms, spacious suites, and family-friendly homes, all with flexible cancellation policies & special deals
Sundown Studio
2 persons
305 sq. feet
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning
room details
Afterglow Suite
2 persons
360 sq. feet
1 King-size bed
Air conditioning
room details
Daybreak Double
2 persons
325 sq. feet
2 Queen Size Beds
Air conditioning
room details
Show all rooms
Price and room availability calendar
Check availability and rates for your selected dates!
Facilities
Enjoy premium amenities for a relaxing stay with your pet
Facilities: Great
8.5/10Review score
General
No smoking on site
Wi-Fi
Free parking
Pets allowed
Rooms/Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key access
Services
Housekeeping
Dining
Picnic area/Tables
Facilities for people with disabilities
Toilet for disabled
Spa & Leisure
Outdoor swimming pool
Garden area
Room features
Air conditioning
Garden furniture
Bathroom
Free toiletries
Show more
Location
82200 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036,
Map view
City landmarks
Museum
History of Diving Museum
4200 ft
Island
Upper Matecumbe Key
2800 ft
Gallery
Lobster Trap Art Gift Shop and Gallery
2500 ft
Gallery
Michelle Nicole Lowe Art Gallery
2500 ft
Gallery
Pasta Pantaleo Signature Gallery
4200 ft
Monument
Hurricane Monument
1.3 mi
Gallery
Gallery Morada
4300 ft
Landmark
In the Doghouse Art Studio
4200 ft
Landmark
Keys History & Discovery Center
2500 ft
Landmark
Indian Key State Historic Site
1.3 mi
Landmark
Carysfort Reef
4200 ft
Gallery
Elena Madden Studio Gallery
4200 ft
Island
Plantation Key
4200 ft
Church
Matecumbe United Methodist Church
4200 ft
Island
Raccoon Key
4200 ft
Gallery
Portside Studio & Gallery
4400 ft
Nearby
Museum
Florida Keys History and Discovery Center
500 ft
Restaurants
Overseas Kitchen
200 ft
82205 Overseas Hwy
Great Wall Taki Outi
1900 ft
82685 Overseas Hwy
Subway
1900 ft
82685 Overseas Highway Bay G
Explore Islamorada
Nearby Activities and Dining
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Florida Keys History and Discovery Center
2 minutes' walk
Cultural insights into the Keys. Features historical exhibits and offers various events, including guided tours.
Lobster Trap Art Gift Shop and Gallery
9 minutes' walk
Local artwork inspired by marine life. Unique souvenirs and gifts from local artists are available.
History of Diving Museum
16 minutes' walk
Dive into the rich history of diving with engaging exhibits. Offers workshops and special events throughout the year.
Carysfort Reef
16 minutes' drive
A stunning coral reef for snorkeling and diving. Ideal for marine enthusiasts seeking underwater adventures.
Kayaking at Windley Key
5 minutes' drive
Rent a kayak and paddle through the mangroves. Guided tours are available, perfect for nature lovers.
Yoga at FNX Club
25 minutes' drive
Relaxing yoga classes in a serene environment. Great option for relaxation and wellness seekers.
Jet Skiing Adventure
5 minutes' drive
Thrilling jet ski rentals available at nearby resorts. A fun way to experience the beautiful waters of the Keys.
Overseas Kitchen
1 minute' walk
Casual eatery known for fresh seafood and classic American dishes. Vegetarian options are available.
Great Wall Taki Outi
7 minutes' walk
Authentic Chinese cuisine with a cozy atmosphere. Favorites include dumplings and Peking duck.
Subway
7 minutes' walk
Fast, healthy sandwich options for a quick meal. Customizable subs cater to various dietary needs.
Hurricane Monument
3 minutes' drive
A historic landmark with a family-friendly park nearby. Great for picnics and taking memorable photos.
FNX Club
25 minutes' drive
Fitness hub with live music events and community gatherings. Family-friendly with activities for all ages.
Getting around
City Centre
Islamorada 4 min · 1000 ft
Bus
Bus stop 12 min · 4.7 mi
Looking for exclusive early booking discounts?
Unlock special rates for your next adventure with your pet today!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 15:00-23:00
Check-out
until 11 am
Internet
Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.
Children & extra beds
There are no cots provided in a room.
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Number of rooms:
31
Reviews and Ratings
Feedback about Sunset Inn from previous guests about their experience.
Breakfast
2.5/10
Cleanliness
8.7/10
Comfort
8.8/10
Facilities
8.5/10
Free Wi-Fi
8.9/10
Location
8.7/10
Paid Wi-Fi
8.5/10
Staff
9.2/10
Value for money
8.4/10
Pros
Friendly staff
Clean rooms
Pool area
Cons
Noisy air conditioner
No microwave
Small bathroom
Guest reviews
based on 1493 reviews
8.4/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.