Save
up to 10%
when booking directly with us!
Check rooms and rates
From115US$ /night
Check-in
31Dec2025Select date
Check-out
01Jan2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Key details

About the Hotel

65 Us Highway 16 E, Buffalo, Wyoming, United States, 82834
-
Close to local attractions
Great
8.2
9.0
/10
4.5
/5

Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo - A Downtown Hotel with Indoor Pool, Fitness Center, and Business Amenities

Located at the crossroads of Interstates 25 and 90, this Buffalo hotel features 62 air-conditioned rooms with flat-screen TVs, laptop-friendly workspaces, and rainfall showerheads. The Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo provides a 24-hour business center, complimentary newspapers, and a 24-hour front desk. Recreational facilities include an indoor pool open from 8 AM, a hot tub, and a fitness center. Each morning, guests receive a free breakfast featuring eggs, breakfast meat, waffles, pastries, yogurt, and cereals. All rooms come equipped with microwaves, refrigerators, coffee makers, and free WiFi. Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western sits within a 5-minute drive of Jim Gatchell Memorial Museum and Buffalo Golf Club. Notable nearby attractions include Lake DeSmet, Fort McKinney, Outlaw Cave, and Clear Creek Brewing Company. Sheridan County Airport is 37 miles from the property.

Pros

Strategic location between Yellowstone National Park and the Black Hills of South Dakota

Free parking available with space for buses

Guest laundry facilities and cold-weather hookups for vehicles

Within 1 mile of cultural spots like In Color Art Gallery, Potters' Depot, and Crazy Woman Fine Art

Cons

Sheridan County Airport is 32 miles away

Restaurant options limited to nearby venues like Albertano's Mexican Restaurant and McDonald's (0.5 miles)

“This roadside accommodation is located conveniently between Yellowstone and the Black Hills. Rooms are somewhat dated, though some have been updated with newer carpeting, so I suggest requesting a renovated room. On the whole, this stop is acceptable for those seeking simple comfort during nature expeditions, with practical facilities for short stays such as an indoor pool and complimentary breakfast.”
Hotel logo
Isabella MooreSenior Editorial Director at Petfriendlyhotels
View all

Select your room type

Cozy rooms, spacious suites, and family-friendly homes, all with flexible cancellation policies & special deals
King Room Disability Access
2 persons
28 m² 
1 King-size bed
Large King Room Non-Smoking
2 persons
28 m² 
1 King-size bed and 1 Sofa bed
King Room Pet-Friendly or Non-Smoking
2 persons
28 m² 
1 King-size bed
Queen Room Two Queen Beds Pet-Friendly or Non-Smoking
2 persons
28 m² 
2 King Size Beds
Click button to see more rooms
Show all rooms
Show all roomsLess

Price and room availability calendar

Check availability and rates for your selected dates!

Facilities

Enjoy premium amenities for a relaxing stay with your pet

General

  • No smoking on site
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Parking
  • Express check-in/ -out
  • Pets allowed
  • Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
  • Security
  • Luggage storage
  • Lift
  • Vending machines
  • Smoke detectors
  • Fire extinguishers

Sports & Fitness

  • Fitness centre

Business

  • Meeting/ Banquet facilities
  • Fax/Photocopying

Spa & Leisure

  • Indoor swimming pool
  • Jacuzzi

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
  • Garden furniture
  • Tea and coffee facilities

Media

  • Flat-screen TV
  • AM/FM alarm clock
Show more

Location

65 Us Highway 16 E, Buffalo, Wyoming, United States, 82834
Map view
65 Us Highway 16 E, Buffalo, Wyoming, United States, 82834
Nearby
Creekside Clubhouse & Greens
300 m
Carousel Park
310 m
Camping
Indian Campground And Rv Park
480 m
Restaurants
Albertano's Mexican Restaurant
480 m
75 N Bypass Rd
Subway
660 m
350 E Hart St Suite A
Hardee's
720 m
104 E Hart St
Explore Buffalo
Nearby Attractions & Activities
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Jim Gatchell Memorial Museum
20 minutes' walk
A museum showcasing local history and Western heritage, featuring artifacts and exhibits, including special events and free admission days.
Johnson County Courthouse
20 minutes' walk
A historic building noted for its beautiful architecture, the courthouse offers guided tours and insights into local governance.
Buffalo Theatre
25 minutes' walk
A charming local theater showcasing films and live performances, it's a perfect spot for an entertaining evening for families and couples alike.
Buffalo Golf Club
20 minutes' walk
An 18-hole golf course offering stunning views and challenging holes, rentals available on-site for enthusiasts of all skill levels.
Carousel Park
4 minutes' walk
A delightful park featuring a carousel and playground, ideal for families looking to unwind with kids and enjoy a picnic.
Albertano's Mexican Restaurant
6 minutes' walk
A vibrant eatery offering authentic Mexican cuisine with beloved dishes like enchiladas and margaritas, perfect for casual dining.
Subway
8 minutes' walk
A popular choice for customizable sandwiches and salads, catering to various dietary needs and great for a quick bite.
Buffalo Food Depot
25 minutes' walk
Featuring local vendors and live events, this market showcases local food and crafts, offering family-friendly entertainment options.
Crazy Woman Fine Art
20 minutes' walk
An art gallery featuring local artists, offering regular exhibits and events, perfect for those wanting to immerse themselves in the local art scene.
Getting around
City Centre
Buffalo16 min  ·  1.3 km
Airports
Sheridan County Airport (SHR)84 min  ·  55.9 km
Gillette, WY (GCC)173 min  ·  114.8 km
Looking for exclusive early booking discounts?
Unlock special rates for your next adventure with your pet today!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-23:59
Check-out
until 11 am
Guest Parking
Public parking is possible on site for free.
Internet
is available in public areas for free.
Breakfast
A american breakfast is served at affordable prices. 
Children & extra beds
There are no extra beds provided in a room. 
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Number of floors:
2
Number of rooms:
63
Former name
Comfort Inn
FAQs
About Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo
What are the check-in and check-out times at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Check-in is from 16:00 and check-out is by 11:00.
Is parking available at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Free public parking is available on-site without reservation needed.
What recreational facilities does Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo offer?
The hotel features an indoor pool, Jacuzzi, and fitness center.
What room amenities are provided at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Rooms include air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, coffee/tea makers, and free Wi-Fi.
What breakfast options are available at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Guests can enjoy a complimentary full breakfast, including eggs, waffles, and yogurt.
Which nearby attractions can guests visit while staying at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Attractions include Jim Gatchell Memorial Museum (5 km), Buffalo Golf Club (5 km), and Bighorn National Forest (close proximity).
What is the distance from Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo to Sheridan County Airport?
The hotel is located 52 km from Sheridan County Airport.
What type of business services are available at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
The hotel offers a 24-hour business center and free local phone calls.
Are there any laundry facilities at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Yes, the hotel provides guest laundry facilities.
What dining options are available near Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Nearby restaurants include Albertano's Mexican Restaurant and McDonald's, both within 0.5 km.
What are the features of the bathrooms in rooms at Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo?
Bathrooms include shower/tub combinations with rainfall showerheads and complimentary toiletries.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.
Check-in
31Dec2025Select date
Check-out
01Jan2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Need more options?
Check Top hotels near Surestay Plus Hotel By Best Western Buffalo
Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo Exterior photo
Mobile-only price

Hampton Inn & Suites Buffalo

8.8
Great255 reviews
216m from property
USD 97USD 87
per night
Rodeway Inn Buffalo Exterior photo
Mobile-only price

Rodeway Inn Buffalo

8.3
Great105 reviews
340m from property
USD 59USD 53
per night
Quality Inn Buffalo Exterior photo
Mobile-only price

Quality Inn Buffalo

7.3
Very good189 reviews
403m from property
USD 118USD 106
per night