Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic Inns, Key West

Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic Inns - A historic collection of conch houses with heated pool in Old Town

Located at the corner of Eaton and Frances streets, this Key West hotel comprises five two-story buildings with white picket fencing and charming front porches. Fitch Lodge occupies turn-of-the-19th-century conch houses, where each room features distinct designs with modern wood-grain wallpaper, turquoise-and-black-striped bed throws, and a mix of nautical and abstract artwork. The 3-star Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic Inns maintains a heated outdoor pool with a red-brick deck and waterfall, plus a palm-shaded breakfast courtyard and second-floor sun deck. Guest rooms include private bathrooms, air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, mini-fridges, security safes, and hairdryers. A complimentary continental breakfast is served poolside each morning under a canopy tent. The property sits 0.5 miles from Duval Street, 1 mile from Key West Aquarium and Shipwreck Museum, and 3 miles from Key West International Airport. Multiple dining options exist within 1640.4 ft, including Ingrid's Key West Kitchen, Old Town Bakery, and Prime Steakhouse.

Pros

Historic conch houses with unique room designs and nautical decor

Second-floor sun deck offers street views and lounge areas

Free street parking available

Walking distance to Key West Historic Seaport for snorkeling and diving excursions

Cons

3 miles distance from airport requires transportation planning

Limited on-site dining options beyond breakfast