The Menhaden Hotel, Greenport

The Menhaden Hotel - A 16-room boutique property with rooftop bar, Mediterranean dining, and harbor views

Situated in the heart of Greenport Village, The Menhaden Hotel stands as a 4-star boutique property featuring 16 rooms with airy, nautical-inspired decor and natural wood accents. Each floor offers a galley kitchen stocked with local snacks, pastries, and beverages. The property houses The Merchant's Wife Mediterranean restaurant with flexible dining layouts and banquette seating. A signature rooftop bar and deck provides sunset views over Greenport Harbor and Shelter Island, complete with firepits and lounge areas. Guests have access to complimentary bikes and the hotel's Moke vehicle for local transportation. The concierge arranges wine tastings at 149 nearby vineyards and boating excursions on Long Island Sound. This Greenport hotel sits within walking distance of shops, art galleries, and the boardwalk.

Pros

Each floor features a complimentary galley with local snacks and fresh pastries

Private water taxi service available to Shelter Island

The only hotel rooftop bar in North Fork with harbor views

Concierge arranges exclusive experiences like private oyster shucking classes

Cons

Located 52.5 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport

Limited parking available on first-come basis